On this page · 9 sections
What would James Hoffmann do differently if he were starting a specialty coffee business in India today, knowing what he had experienced building one in London?
That was the question I asked him towards the end of his session at Roast CCx in Hyderabad on 21 November. His answer was less about coffee businesses than about the people they serve.
I had gone to the event with a particular interest in the economics of Indian specialty coffee. While building IndianCoffeeBeans.com, I have spent a fair amount of time looking at the coffees that Indian roasters sell, the origins they source from and the ways they describe their products. I brought along a short research brief based on that catalogue to share with him. What I wanted to understand, though, was something the catalogue cannot answer on its own: how do we get more people interested in these coffees in the first place?
The talk, hosted by Brewing Gadgets, covered much of the coffee supply chain. There was plenty about production and the volatility of the global market, but also the economics of roasting and cafés, the changing expectations of drinkers and the peculiar habits of the specialty coffee industry itself. Throughout, I kept coming back to one question: which of these lessons can India use before it encounters the same problems?
The cost of coffee is not just a price problem
Hoffmann began with a market that has little room for error. Global coffee production and consumption are closely matched, he argued, while the stock buffers that once helped absorb disruptions have diminished. A bad harvest has consequences far beyond the farms affected by it.
His observation about recent price increases was more interesting than the increases themselves. For years, he said, the industry had argued that it could not afford to pay producers substantially more. The recent period of higher prices has shown that businesses can operate at those prices, albeit in difficult circumstances. The problem is that this experiment has coincided with rising rents, labour costs and the wider cost-of-living crisis. It has been a particularly difficult moment to establish whether a more remunerative model can work.
Brazil occupied a large part of this discussion. Its scale, mechanised harvesting and the financial capacity of some producers to hold back coffee distinguish it from many other origins. For a roaster buying elsewhere, changes in Brazilian supply can still affect the price paid to the producer. The reverse influence is much weaker.
Climate adds another layer of uncertainty. Hoffmann discussed the possibility of production losses associated with El Niño, including an estimate he had heard from a coffee systems expert. These were scenarios rather than a confirmed forecast. His larger point was that buyers need to be prepared for volatility rather than assume a predictable price of green coffee.
There is a distinction worth making here for India. A higher price for a roasted bag does not, by itself, tell us how much more the farmer received. Nor does a lower price necessarily indicate a more efficient or sustainable supply chain. Those are questions about costs, contracts and relationships, not just retail price. It is one reason I think price comparisons need more context as the Indian market develops.
Robusta is not a simple climate solution
The discussion of Robusta was one of the parts of the production section I found most relevant to India.
Hoffmann challenged the assumption that switching from Arabica to Robusta is a straightforward adaptation to a warming climate. He described research suggesting that Robusta's relative tolerance of higher temperatures should not be confused with tolerance of drought. The timing and continuity of available moisture matter. Irrigation may address one problem while creating another if the water supply itself is unsustainable.
He was particularly concerned about highly intensive production systems involving full sun, fertiliser and irrigation. His point was not that all Robusta should be avoided, but that the environmental consequences of the production system need to be understood before it is promoted as a solution to climate change. Other species, including Liberica and Excelsa, also deserve consideration in that conversation.
That is a useful distinction in a country where both Arabica and Robusta are already part of the growing landscape. A species name tells us less about sustainability than we might like it to. Water availability, shade, yield and the landscape in which coffee is grown all matter. As Hoffmann noted, specialty coffee has traditionally discussed varieties through their flavour characteristics; future conversations may increasingly need to consider productivity as well.
The implication for buyers is not to favour one species indiscriminately. It is to ask more specific questions about where and how a coffee was grown.
India has an advantage that cannot be imported
One of the most memorable parts of the afternoon was Hoffmann's account of drinking locally grown coffee in China and India. He had found exceptional Chinese coffees in China, and said his experience in India reinforced the idea that some of the finest coffees from producing countries should be encountered in the countries themselves.
“I think the world should travel to India to drink the best Indian coffees.”
That is a compelling reversal of the familiar idea that a producing country's finest coffee must find its way to a buyer overseas. It is an observation about the opportunity for the domestic market, not evidence that the quality distribution of Indian exports has already changed. Establishing that would require data well beyond retail listings.
What interested me more was the commercial logic that accompanied it. Hoffmann argued that Indian roasters have an advantage over buyers based much further away: their proximity to producers. He described a longstanding relationship between his company and a Costa Rican producer. When market prices rose sharply, the producer offered to retain the previous year's price, in recognition of the years in which the roaster had paid well. The arrangement benefited both sides at different points in the market cycle.
For Indian roasters, that suggests a reason to invest in relationships before competition for desirable lots intensifies. Supporting a producer through an experiment, a difficult crop or a new approach to processing may prove more valuable over time than simply being able to acquire an unusual coffee first.
For consumers, it raises a different question: do we know enough about the producers behind the coffees we buy? The relationship between a roaster and an estate is often more informative than a particularly elaborate set of tasting notes. The relationship between Indian exports and domestic specialty coffee deserves attention precisely because consumers here have access to both sides of that market.
China is a reminder that the market can change quickly
The move from production to consumption took us through China, which Hoffmann compared to Brazil in terms of its potential global influence, but on the demand side rather than the supply side.
The expansion of Luckin and Cotti was his illustration of how quickly a market can change. He described rapid store openings, low-priced drinks, app-based promotions and efforts to secure green coffee supply in advance. Even a modest increase in average consumption across such a large population could have an outsized effect on global demand.
I would not take China's model as a playbook for Indian specialty roasters. The businesses, pricing and consumption habits are different. What I take from it is that India's current size as a consuming market should not be mistaken for its permanent size. The demand that emerges here could come from specialty cafés and home brewers, but it could also come from businesses with very different ideas about coffee, convenience and price.
The interesting question is what part of that future a locally rooted specialty industry can create for itself.
Grow the pie before fighting over the slices
Hoffmann used an imaginary pie chart to explain the evolution of his roasting business in London. When he started in 2008, specialty coffee was a small market with relatively few businesses serving it. Even as a small business, his company could take a large slice of it. The work was to bring more people into the category.
Years later, the market had grown, but so had the number of competitors. The emphasis shifted from creating coffee drinkers to acquiring customers who already bought specialty coffee. To grow, a business increasingly needed to persuade a customer to switch from another roaster or café.
It was an analogy rather than a quantitative account of London's market share. But it described a tension I recognise in India. New coffees, cafés and roasters appear regularly, and it is easy to mistake more choice for growth in the number of people making those choices. The two are not necessarily moving at the same rate.
Hoffmann also described a less obvious consequence of a message that specialty coffee has communicated very effectively: this coffee tastes different from that one. A customer discovers that coffee can be fruity or floral, then naturally wants to find out what else it can taste like. They explore different roasters, often buying from each only occasionally. It is not surprising that the business which first encouraged that behaviour struggles to retain the customer.
Discovery is not the problem. The industry has to consider what happens after discovery. Hoffmann described the point at which the drinker has explored widely enough to know what they enjoy and begins asking whom they can trust. That is when regular purchases and subscriptions become possible.
I find this especially relevant to building a discovery platform. Encouraging people to try different coffees makes sense when they are still finding their preferences. Helping someone remember a coffee they enjoyed, or return to a roaster they trust, is equally valuable. A healthy market needs both behaviours.
The financial consequences of intense competition were another part of the talk. Hoffmann described shrinking margins, constrained access to patient capital and fatigue among UK business owners. Those conditions make acquisitions and roll-ups more attractive. His advice was to consider what kind of growth is being pursued, and what obligations accompany outside investment.
India need not arrive at precisely the same destination. But it is worth paying attention to the distinction between creating new demand and redistributing existing demand while there is still considerable room for the former.
Consumer trust is more valuable than novelty
Hoffmann was not dismissive of coffees made with unusual processing techniques. On the contrary, he acknowledged how appealing a coffee that unmistakably tastes of a familiar fruit can be to someone new to specialty. The description is understandable, the taste delivers on an expectation, and the drinker has a reason to be curious.
His concern was with the terminology around co-fermentation and infusion. He questioned whether some coffees sold as co-ferments were more accurately described as infused, and argued that putting fruit in a fermentation tank is not the same as adding flavouring to it. He was asking for greater clarity about what actually goes into the tank, rather than calling for the industry to stop producing flavoured coffees.
The concern is important enough to separate from the specific scientific argument, which would need independent verification. A consumer might happily buy an infused coffee, a fruit co-ferment or a conventional natural, but those are not interchangeable descriptions. Problems arise when the expectation attached to a label is not what the process actually involved.
For me, that makes transparency part of the experience of choosing a coffee. I would like to see more precise product descriptions, with an explicit distinction between tasting notes, added ingredients and processing methods. There is no need to suggest that one category is intrinsically superior to another. There is a need to describe it accurately. Our guide to co-fermentation in Indian specialty coffee explores some of those distinctions.
An interesting parallel emerged later when Hoffmann discussed AI. He was sceptical of treating AI as a single answer to the problems of roasting. Even a large collection of roast profiles is limited if the associated tasting data are noisy or influenced by what tasters have been told. He was also cautious about generative AI in consumer-facing parts of a coffee business, where it can communicate a lack of care.
As someone who spends a considerable amount of time working with coffee data and technology, I found this a useful challenge. Structuring information and analysing patterns is one thing. Manufacturing certainty about an inherently subjective sensory experience is something else. A roaster's description and a consumer's observation should be distinguishable, and neither should be represented as an independently measured cup score.
What makes a coffee shop special when home coffee is good?
The economics of cafés were another thread in the talk. Large chains once had relatively clear advantages in location, predictable service and price. In several mature markets, Hoffmann argued, rising costs have weakened that proposition. An independent specialty café can now be a more persuasive choice when the price difference is small.
At the same time, cafés have a new competitor: the customer at home. Equipment has improved, good brewing information is accessible, and a home brewer can make drinks that once required a trip to a specialty shop. Hoffmann expects that part of the market to grow in India too.
At Prufrock, the London café he is associated with, visitors can arrive with very high expectations after spending hours watching his videos. However well a cup is prepared, there is a limit to how much it can exceed those expectations. His observation was that a warm welcome can do more to improve the experience than another increment of technical refinement.
He explored the same idea through matcha and café signature drinks. Matcha has different price expectations from coffee, and the appeal of a distinctive drink need not rest entirely on the technical properties of its main ingredient. A café that serves a drink people enjoy but would not ordinarily make at home offers a reason to visit beyond the quality of its espresso.
For India, the point is worth considering alongside the range of formats in which coffee is already consumed here. Cafés do not all need to earn their place by serving the same drinks in the same way. Nor do home brewers need to replicate the café experience to be part of a specialty coffee culture.
Two questions from the room that deserve a longer conversation
The Q&A offered two particularly interesting opportunities for India. Asked why Indian filter coffee had not spread globally, Hoffmann questioned whether it needed to. The increasing similarity of specialty café menus across countries troubled him. A drink that belongs to a place can make going to that place more interesting.
I would take that argument a step further. South Indian filter coffee has a story, preparation method and cultural context of its own. It need not compete with a flat white on the flat white's terms. It can be appreciated on its own terms, here or abroad, without being redesigned to fit somebody else's definition of specialty.
Another question concerned including India in Hoffmann's large collaborative tasting projects. He explained the difficulties involved in shipping coffee across borders and the role import duties played in limiting participation. The interesting part of his answer was his encouragement to Indian roasters to organise their own projects: comparable samples, prepared in different ways and tasted together online. He indicated he would be interested in supporting and promoting a locally organised project.
This was a general invitation to the industry, not a commitment to any particular organisation. Even so, the format seems worth exploring. A collaborative tasting can bring together people who would otherwise discover coffee entirely on their own. If participants share what they actually perceive, the conversation becomes richer than simply explaining the correct tasting notes in advance.
Curiosity before education
My question came last. I mentioned the low per-person coffee consumption in India and asked how Hoffmann would build the consumer market here, given his experience in London.
His first objection was to the word better. Telling people that what you serve is better can imply that their existing preferences are mistaken. An industry trying to invite more people in might be more successful if it offers something more enjoyable rather than asks them to abandon what they already enjoy.
He then described a rule from his café: do not educate a customer who has not asked a question. Let them order, give them something enjoyable, and give them room to be curious. If the coffee makes them wonder why it tastes of strawberries, there is an opportunity for a conversation that the customer has initiated.
“Our goal is not education. Our goal is to drive curiosity. And if we do that, education solves itself.”
He applied that principle to retail environments both online and in person. I have been thinking about it in the context of ICB ever since.
A directory is easy to build as a list of answers: scores, rankings, verdicts. But what a person remembers is the first time a cup surprised them and they went looking for why. If a page can leave a reader wanting to open the next bag, explore another roaster or understand where a particular coffee comes from, the explaining will mostly take care of itself.
There is a balance to strike. People who want detailed information should be able to find it. Those who simply want a coffee that they will enjoy should not be made to feel that they need an education before buying one. And those who are perfectly happy drinking the same coffee every morning are just as much a part of this market as those who try a new processing method every week.
That is what I took out of the room. Discovery is the part worth protecting.
Source note: These are my first-person notes from James Hoffmann Live in Hyderabad, hosted by Brewing Gadgets at Roast CCx on 21 November 2026. They draw on my attendance and a partial recording of the talk and Q&A. The article rearranges and condenses topics for clarity. Remarks attributed to Hoffmann reflect the session, not independently verified ICB findings. My own interpretations are identified in the text. Thanks to the organisers for bringing the conversation to Hyderabad.
Meet the roasters
Explore Indian specialty coffee roasters and their coffees.
Browse on ICB →
